Quote Originally Posted by doommachine View Post
Melee is by far my favorite over casters. I havent meant to be so stubborn about it. I came in asking how to make melee work and you people with the experience are basicaly saying not to even try it. I should listen and will likely be proven wrong. We shall see what happens. I havent even started my teams yet. Lol. Plenty of time to decide to go all or mostly all casters. And in reality (i believe) those that were successful with melee did it around the end of wrath after the nerfs and they were overgeared for the places. Which makes it far easier than trying to replicate it in cata even 6 months from now. Thank you for your help and opinions. I cant wait to share my results with you no matter what they are.
Being one of the original melee boxers, let me tell you, your single biggest pain will be encounter design based on the concept of ranged DPS being at, well, range. It doesn't come up often, but when it does its REALLY annoying. Nothing quite like everyone needing to be spread out so far or a whirlwind that is there just as a big "F You" to all melee teams. You don't see it too much in 5-man, particularly now with the LFG tool meaning you may get a misbalanced team for such things, but for raids, they plan around composition, and all melee is a no go. But, your money.