Quote Originally Posted by Boylston View Post
If you're targeting PvE as a primary concern, I think you should consider the following 3-class arrangement:

Feral Druid (Bear) Tank + Enhancement + 3xRetribution

You'll get a great selection of buffs plus great passive healing plus Bloodlust/buffage. Bear brings stuff that's not-redundant compared to Prot Pally or DK, like iLotP and MotW. An enhance shaman replaces most all of the buffage you could get from the DK and adds other wonderful buffs. If you wanted to tank with a prot pally, I'd also recommend Prot Pally + 2x Ret + Enhance + Kitty for the buffs, although I think it's easier to manage DPS with 2 classes instead of 3.

Depending on the degree of PvP you want to mix in, there are many other options. May also want to wait until we know more about Cataclysm mechanics before you lock your setup into stone. 4xHealing Hands might be OP and then I'd default back to a DK+4xRet setup.
I'd have to agree with Boylston. With current mechanics pre cataclysm, this PVE composition with the feral tank seems like it covers all of your bases well without too much micromanagement:

http://raidcomp.mmo-champion.com/?c=...00000000000000

Add Runescroll of Fortitude (Very cheap to make with inscription) for the missing stam buff. Now you have all the major melee buffs, wipe recovery, and fear recovery.

However, with all of this said...I'd personally wait until Cataclysm before making any decisions