Bringing this thread back (kinda) from the dead:

I have an all Paladin team (and I also can swap my tank out to have 4 shaman as well - 1 resto, 3 enhance, or whatever configuration works) - and I am *finally* making progress in handling heroics.

My tank is now geared 100% in stuff that you can trade Triumph badges for (still need a trinket other than the Black Heart, though) and the rest of my team is wearing (mostly) crafted blues, a the 2 crafted epics (head and feet) and then a couple of drops from normal FoS and PoS - so we don't exactly outgear the content but we're getting there.

What I'm noticing is that some heroic dungeons are absolutely trivial - Draktharon was easy, including King Dred (without any fear mitigation on the paladins, even), Old Kingdom. Some "normal but heroic" fights are also nothing - Brojham, Garfrost are easy. Others, however, completely ruin me - I cannot get past Hydronox in Anub on heroic (I get it to about 45%), and other fights in some dungeons where having real range is a huge advantage.

Some dungeons I haven't even tried the other bosses - for example, normal PoS, I haven't even tried Krik and Ick or whosit the dragon guy yet - I'm wondering, for an all melee team, how hard are those fights? I'm going to try to get past PoS tonight, so that I can do HoR and hopefully farm that shield off of Marwyn as that would be a nice upgrade for my tank.

For people playing all melee teams, what are your easy instances? What are the fights that just brutalize you?