new team, trying to be a little different..

[fightcow]

I'd really like to rip you a new one since you make it so easy, but I'm just going to say bad.

I didnt ask you to rate my choice, i asked for 'good or bad feedback'. hmm maybe yours counts, its bad.

but to everyone else, thanks for your thoughts i feel i should clarify that im not trying to make an uber team or even make it easy on myself, ive done that with the standard healer-tank-dps, maybe it cant be done any other way... i wanna try though just for fun.

for aggro help i can use righteous fury, increase threat by 80% of all holy spells, inc healing afaik.
also i can talent the lock dps to reduce threat by 30%(i think, or 20%..)
and taunts, consecration, judgements etc

loss of avoidance while casting is something i hadnt thought of, so thats a bummer! what about dodge?

healing with FoL and sacred shield and fusion of light should be quite helpful, 50%crit chance and 100% Hot..

tbh, its loss of mobility that im starting to worry about now.. really appreciated that with the druid and BM hunters.

[genocyde]

Well I say give it a shot. Worst case scenario is you end up running prot pally 4x dps. I can think of quite a few heroics where that is an option.

[Ughmahedhurtz]

Such a charming dude.

As our token skeptic/cynic/prophet of doom, I find his posts hilarious. Says what many of us are thinking, in that crotchety-old-man style, without the arrogance that some of our more well known loudmouths tend to exhibit.

As for feedback on the OP's idea, I'm pretty sure we've fairly exhaustively debunked any ideas about pally tanks being able to keep aggro through heals and live.

[fightcow]

As our token skeptic/cynic/prophet of doom, I find his posts hilarious. Says what many of us are thinking, in that crotchety-old-man style, without the arrogance that some of our more well known loudmouths tend to exhibit.

As for feedback on the OP's idea, I'm pretty sure we've fairly exhaustively debunked any ideas about pally tanks being able to keep aggro through heals and live.

many of you were thinking 'i really want to rip him a new one' ??
for asking for feedback on an idea..

nice, thanks for that.

[genocyde]

Pretty sure Ugh was just referring to Naysayer's average post not that one in particular.

By no means does Naysayer represent the average person on this forum and from what I've seen many do not like him or negative posts at all.

I'll give him the crotchety-old-man style funny factor though sometimes and his avatar is win considering his post style.

[Ughmahedhurtz]

many of you were thinking 'i really want to rip him a new one' ??
for asking for feedback on an idea..

nice, thanks for that.

/facepalm

Some of you have zero imagination or sense of humor. You really should try improving your outlook on life.

[fightcow]

/facepalm

Some of you have zero imagination or sense of humor. You really should try improving your outlook on life.

one day, if i try real hard, do you think i could be as cool as you..

funny and imaginative enough for ya boss?

[Ughmahedhurtz]

one day, if i try real hard, do you think i could be as cool as you..

funny and imaginative enough for ya boss?

<gunny>YOU DON'T SCARE ME! WORK ON IT!</gunny> ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pyg05bw-xH8 )