I liked Hellboy II - mild spoilers below.

[spoiler]But I wouldn't have believed you if you told me I'd hear Barry Manilow. :P Guillermo del Toro produces some interesting looking visuals. del Toro is noted as being the director for the upcoming "The Hobbit" movie, so I'm excited about that. I was *fascinated* by the creatures and the environments in HellBoy II. It was funny in places and I liked the story, a bit of emo to push it along. No massive fight scenes, but some of the creatures made what fights there were interesting. I'd watch it again, but not immediately.[/spoiler]