There is a difference between stupid elitism and common sense. Personally I have a lot of resistance myself to get into more experienced / skilled groups when I'm not at their level (yet). Not so true anymore for wow at the moment, but that is a general attitude I have in games. Not that I lack confidence, more that I have a realistic view on my skills and I don't want to fuck up fellow players their game. The only thing I expect from players who play in my group, is that they do their best.
In wow doing your best means that you read the tooltips, your spells and your talents. That you think for a second how much damage a certain spell does and how you can contribute to your goup. That doesn't mean that you should know each and every tactic in the game. But doing also means that you ask for help or inform others that you are unsure about something.
I don't see why they couldn't join battlegrounds when they have no experience. Getting killed over and over only affects yourself, and not so much the whole group. In a heroic dungeon however, you screw it up for others. It seems that heroics are considered trivial content, and that newly dinged lvl 80 players should start there. Well I strongly disagree. There is also a normal version of the dungeons, it's called heroics for a good reason. There are enough means to get better at something without screwing other players up.
Today I was queuing up with my tank for a random hc, HoL. As I'm pretty well geared (59k hp buffed), I chain pulled the first packs, the priest ran oom and we wiped. He felt sorry and told so in party chat. But he did what he could do and it was my fault to judge wrong. He just dinged 80 with his first toon and his brother warlock was doing a first HC with him, so he could not get kicked. There was also a warrior and a dk. Warrior did 3K over dungeon, lock 1.6 and dk 1.1. We wiped 2 more times when the priest ninja pulled a couple of mobs right before 2nd boss. But that was just inexperience. But he asked questions about where to stand, he informed me when he was low on mana and when he had a cooldown. Everyone stayed the whole dungeon, and after about 50 minutes we cleared it. And we ended up doing a couple more hc's flawlessly minus the dk. Long story short: the priest clearly did his best, he was just inexperienced. But he realized that and showed a good attitude. And I rather spend time in the game with someone like him over a moronic player in fancy epics who doesn't have a clue how to play his class and says 'lolz m8 relax, itz only game, I dont need gems'.
That being said, I think the post you referred to was meant for multiboxers. There is always a 50% chance that a player is either bad or good. If you bring more than 1 toon into a bg, and you are bad, you basically increase the groups bad ratio, and you should imo refrain from doing it, because you screw up other players their game. Until you are good enough to bring multiple toons into a small BG to not affect the groups bad ratio, stick to AV, wintergrasp or isle of conquest to practice.
Connect With Us