(spoiler) Holy Sweet Jesus (spoiler)

[Naysayer]

Somehow i wasn't impressed by the quality of the video or the story.

As was mentioned in the previous posts, it really feels a bit like, "Ok you've killed THE Lick King, but don't worry, here's another one for later".
I've only just started reading the Christie Golden books however, so can't comment much on the lore part at the moment.


The video however was a bit disappointing, and although the editing/screenplay is nice, the quality of the rendering is sad.
1. it's all close-ups plans (except the final view of the throne) and 3D toons in close-up just don't work for me (sharp angles, fixed expressions etc)
The images look awesome from afar, but when you zoom in it's just not as good.
2. long periods on faces. Rendering emotions in 3D characters >.< ... plus really Arthas has a retarded face. Play the vid again if you didn't notice.
3. effects are lame. Honestly the fire effects on bolvar are Meh, (apart from the first glimpse of his hands when he first appears) the rest of the body could have used a couple more hours of work to have a smoke or glow effect of some sort.
4. compared to the wrathgate cut scene for example, it's pathetic. only 4 toons (when there will be a few around when Arthas dies i'm sure), the whole sequence holds in a 10 square meter area. the best toon is Tirion as he is most seen from a little distance, and has an awesome armor to go with.

just my thoughts anyway. i'll go check it again in a sec to see if it still feels the same.

^^ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lzyd91NFx-Y

[Seraphaw]

All in all, i didn't like it. It feels more like another fan-made movie on warcraftmovies.com

Posting again, I have to agree with Remanz. They have spent almost a decade on this storyline and we could not even get a masterfully made CGI scene.

(For the record, falsetto choir music is just overindulgent, the music in WC3 when they fight with Mannoroth is at least subtle and sets the mood)

[boxblizzard]

erm sorry for being slightly off topic....

but those patch notes are making things EZ MODE, look at what they done to old kingdom..... cmon wtf

[Khatovar]

I couldn't stop snickering at those absurd Grateful Dead...errr...Shaman....I mean Paladin shoulders.

[Zub]

Using real time rendered models instead pre-rended CG is a giant step backwards. All in all, i didn't like it. It feels more like another fan-made movie on warcraftmovies.com

lol this is so true.

Actually, to really compare to another video, I would one with the similar storyline, when Arthas actually becomes Lich King:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DHY85O8mFo8

Awesome Video, so many many times better than this 'new' lich king one.

[Lokked]

I got some shivers, but only from the audio and the overall setting.

It really is sad that they didn't at least use the high-poly models in place of the game's low-polys for purposes of a scripted scene.

The expressionless faces (save a few eyebrow movements) made me think of certain Steven Segall movies. But I don't expect Blizzard graphics designers to understand body language.

[zipzip]

That video was made by blizzard? I'm disappointed in the quality...truly terrible, relatively speaking.

[crowdx]

What did everyone expect from such a small patch? To have rendered this as a proper cut scene would have taken a lot more bandwidth to allow people to download it and obviously Blizzard decided to go low bandwidth. From what I recall, only the game expansions have ever gotten a fully rendered cgi cut scene?

[remanz]

What did everyone expect from such a small patch? To have rendered this as a proper cut scene would have taken a lot more bandwidth to allow people to download it and obviously Blizzard decided to go low bandwidth. From what I recall, only the game expansions have ever gotten a fully rendered cgi cut scene?

It is a video file. how does CGI cut scene vs in-game engine cut scene matter ? The resolution of the video determines the file size, not the content. And if file size is a problem, they can always split them into different packs. I don't think that can justify the low quality content (not low quality video file).

I have no problem with the way it ended. Only if they can spend a little more resource on this. After all, this marks the end of a 5 year WOW. and I am pretty sure a lot of people have been waiting for this since WC3.

[Maxion]

It is a video file. how does CGI cut scene vs in-game engine cut scene matter ? The resolution of the video determines the file size, not the content. And if file size is a problem, they can always split them into different packs. I don't think that can justify the low quality content (not low quality video file).

I have no problem with the way it ended. Only if they can spend a little more resource on this. After all, this marks the end of a 5 year WOW. and I am pretty sure a lot of people have been waiting for this since WC3.

I'm pretty sure this is not the end of WoW. :P

Also, the video has been taken down by blizzard, so I'll just have to kill the lich king myself to see it, oh well