Quote Originally Posted by 'Lyonheart',index.php?page=Thread&postID=89804#pos t89804
Quote Originally Posted by 'Suvega',index.php?page=Thread&postID=89714#post89 714
My conclusion from seeing 10 mans, and doing them with vyndree is:

Most viable tank - Paladin
HOWEVER, you ahve to wait until he is -really- overgeared. Otherwise threat/mitigation/mana issues will arise from tanking mobs that were intended to be cc'ed.

Second most viable - Druid
Less buttons, good threat and avoidance given on par gear with instance

Least viable - War
MICRO MANAGEMENT HELL - however can deal w many diff issues if you're pro. (like me )
How over geared? For Kara, should the paly be hero badged out? If i remember right my guild was clearing kara before anyone was doing heroics. In fact i think Kara helped us do heroics more reliably lol.
A paladin tank willl need prob at least upper t4 -> t5 (better then all kara gear), to tank packs of mobs with no CC.

I would expect the same in WOTLK. Basically wheny our tank needs nothing from an instance, you can prob aoe tank groups that are intended to be CCEd.