I would NOT recommend the warrior as a tank for your five box team. Warrior is a great tank if that is all you are playing but takes WAY too much concentration to keep agro on large groups.

They do take a hell of a pounding but I would recommend sticking with your pally. What is your team makeup?

BTW: You can't really derail this thread as there were no real rails to begin with. I just felt like posting what I was up to.