S2 Gavel > Continuum Blade.
If you got your shamans their weapon and shield, you can get your pally the gavel.

Im still wearing the blue Righteous Shoulders on my pally tank. When the shoulder drop off Netherspite 2 weeks ago, some 8 year old warrior (literal noob) rolled need on it. I forgot to set it back to masterloot, so an 8 year old pwned me.

Grats on the 10-man, very inspiring.

I think the reason Attumen can't be 5-man by Pally + 4Shamans is there needs to be a decurse in the encounter.