Ok, it seems that today is the day that I keep answering my own posts....

...but if I had not posted, I would not have figured it out!!!

You have to set the Logitech Software to Enable Persistant Profile (under Profiler in Settings).

Otherwise, it will only work for the character you setup the first time. Why G1 was working is probably due to the large amounts of angry brain waves I was sending to it.

All my keys work now! Thank you, white posting space, for helping me through this stupid problem.