Ok so I'm planning ahead to when I get my hardware (I'm a OCD planner and I wanna have my macros written and ready to go when I have my hardware in place).

I've decided to go with a Blood-Elf 5man PvE Team, my fiancee switched Horde and has been on me to roll Horde too. But I've seen the problems she has getting groups and I want to make it so we can just 2man any instances we want. And since Prot Pallies make boxing an instance easy, Blood Elves are the choice.

Now she plays a MM hunter, so she's going to be pretty much worthless in the way of buffs for my 5man unless I go with at least 2 hunters. But I want some CC.

I've decided to go with at least 1 BM hunter (for FI).

So the base 3 is going to be Prot Pally, Holy Priest and BM Hunter.

The dilemma is: for the other 2, do I go with:
#1 2 mages for sheepx2
#2 mage + BM hunter(And switch the BM hunter out for my fiancee when she wants to instance and otherwise have FIx2 when I'm 5boxing
#3 Mage + Warlock (soulstones, healthstones, etc)
#4 BM Hunterx2 and screw the CC with FIx3 for 9%dmg in a 5man

Right now I'm leaning toward either #1 or #2.

Any input?