Thinking about a reroll for my 5 man

[Sovereign]

I am wondering if I should reroll my x5. It's currently a Prot War, Holy Priest, 3x afflock.

It works pretty well, but I am worried about holding AoE aggro and noticing certain 1 class 5 mans may even do better.

Also I was looking at the 4 lock 1 shadow priest combo thinking that subbing out 1 lock for an additional shadow priest would almost certainly be a more deadly combination.

Any thoughts?

edit: Oh, just a note, I have a level 18 (same level as my toons, but diff race) Blood Elf paladin that I could sub in as the tank to change the group. It's a different race, so somewhat ruins the group, but has maybe a bonus by being a Blood Elf Paladin controlling 4 undead minions.

Oh the decisions. Someone help me make it, heh.

[Bunny]

Drop the Warrior imho
I have multiboxed the holy trinity (tank healer 3dps) with a warrior and although it is possible it is hard. Althoung I have not actually tried I assume that a prot paladin requires much less attention and is much better on aoe pulls.
Bunny

[OzPhoenix]

Paladins certainly seem to be preferred over Warriors for boxing.

[Jaws5]

Since you have some cc you should still beable to do it with War. Wars have more options for armor and some of the best tanking can be done , but it requires a lot of micro management. War has to be your main. I run with 1 war 3 mages and holy priest I prefer war for some instances . I also have paly on same account as war to tank other inastances that are not war frindlley. it all depends on instance. My war is undead so wotf is nice.

I also run with 1 shadow priest and 4 locks on pvp server, this grp can do all normal instances but can not do many heroic ones. blueberries do not stand up well but since there are 4 they can last long enough for dps and fears to do the job.

The easiest grp to do Herioc for me so far is Paladin 3 mages and Holy priest. I m working on 5 druids , 5 shammy and 5 hunters. so time will tell.