Heya. I have 4 Shamans on Alliance.

I have to get rid of one, cause its account name differs from my own (I know now, I didnt when I started)

SO, my question is, should I lvl 2 more Shamans, to make an even team of 5 Shamans, or a Pally and a Shaman, for ease of 5 man content including Heroics.

Anybody who has one of these setups pls chime in, im interested to hear your thoughts and if you could reroll whether you would do the same.

Here is where I am at:

A Paladin would be nice, id go prot obviously, and it would provide great buffs for the group on heroic content, as well as in Kara etc etc

Another Shaman would make it a lot easier to get PvP gear on that toon, as a prot pally isn't worth much in arenas / BG's.

Do you guys with 5 shamans find heroics have a ceiling you hit where not having a tank is absolutely detrimental? or can you suffice without too much trouble.
Do you guys with a prot pally find your tank doesn't tank as well as you thought and maybe another DPS would be just fine?