They took me to Hyjal!

[Gallo]

It would be as tho you couldn't have two shadow priests in a group and everyone benefiting from their regen etc

Totally forgot about that arguement. That seals it for me.

[Ðeceased]

I get the impression that blizz is allowing for more stacking in general anyway tho. U guys remember the days when you could only have one hot per class on someone at a time? /wrists
I have to say i'm still a little dissapointed they don't allow more.

I've always tried to push the argument that all non-active- non-talanted buffs should be able to stack on a penalty system. (this excludes ToW, BoK, BoP, Priesty Spirit buffage, ehn shaman AP buff to group members - all these would have individual conditions based on their overall effectiveness)

say for instance Paladin blessings
(I've made up the AP boost here btw)

AP Blessing:500AP
2xAP: 750AP
3xAP: 875AP
4xAP: 1000AP
5xAP: 1125AP

as you can see the percentile is

100%
50%
25%
25%
25%

these would only be effective if in the same group.

so you couldn't have 100 paladins buff you insanely..

[Gallo]

If they ever start to make more 10-man's in order to lower the req'd raiding number, they just might adopt a stacking system like that. All the min-maxers would have a field day with all the different combos.

[Tdog]

say for instance Paladin blessings
(I've made up the AP boost here btw)

AP Blessing:500AP
2xAP: 750AP
3xAP: 875AP
4xAP: 1000AP
5xAP: 1125AP

as you can see the percentile is

100%
50%
25%
25%
25%

these would only be effective if in the same group.

so you couldn't have 100 paladins buff you insanely..

Ah come on...
An extra 3000 ap from BoM
or an extra 400 mp5 from BoW
or an extra 75% threat reduction from BoS

That's hardly OP