I guess "no guild" was an overstatement, but it's still only going to bring a hunter from a B grade DPS to A grade at the cost of splitting the same loot between 25 or so of the same class, then all 40 people are going to have to raid like they are going for records (aka restorative pots and top of the line DPS to avoid curses) when they could never reach that goal of topping records, it would be like 40 man Priest Ony, a gimmick and then quickly nerfed.