Paladin vs Warrior tank decision help.

[nodoze]

The optimal discussion isn't just Warrior Tank vs Paladin Tank... If you go Warrior Tank your threat is best with a Paladin Healer but you do lose some things by losing a Priest... Going Paladin tank means you can go with a Priest healer and gives the party lots of utility:

Tank bubble pulls.
Tank bubbles Priest or other party members to save them;
Tank sacrifice self to prevent wipe (did that in my melee team yesterday).
Tank being able to cleanse the primary healer;
Tank being able to heal the primary healer;
Tank being able to off heal to finish a fight if main healer goes down;
Tank being able to double healing output in some scenarios;
Tank cleanse self;
Tank being able to cast non-pushback heals on self;
Tank being able to Lay on Hands on anyone then pop mana potion;
Tank being able to rez the Priest/party;
Priest bubble Tank (and not hurt Threat much) to help smooth things out;
Priest HoT Tank to help smooth things out;
Priest bubble Eye of Killrog for easier pulls;
Fear Ward on Tank;
Fear Ward on Healer (&/or other party members);
+25% armor on Tank/Party from Priest heals;
Extra Stamina across the party;
Extra Spirit across the party;
AoE healing options;
Healer being able to contribute to DPS from range when not healing;
2 Healers if you take your party into PVP;

And those are just the benefits off the top of my head and they add up to a lot increasing the Quality of Life for a MultiBoxer (especially a newer one).