Is my 5-man Comp Crazy?

[nodoze]

BGs are the focus for my brother & I and I need my team to have 1 Paladin for me and 1 Warrior & 1 Paladin for him (we will likely still both solo queue on our Paladins when alone but instead of only queueing duo Paladins like we did in Vanilla->WoTLK I want us to be able to also try Warrior+Paladin)... I say that because he always played his Paladin like a Warrior (often a Ret/Prot mix) with me being his healer (maybe Shockadin so I can have some burst DPS as well). He usually won't play a full healing Paladin (only off-healing his healer) but if I know another full healer is going to queue with us I would like the option to also main a Warrior as well (so we can go 2 Warriors + 1 Healer instead of 1 Warrior+2 Healers) so 2 Paladins + 2 Warriors gives both of us both options...

So starting with a minimum of 2 Paladins +1 Warrior makes 2 Paladins + 3 Warriors a good fit (especially considering Melee-Cleave is supposed to be hyper-efficient for PVE and 2 Healers optimal for WPVP)...

Regarding group composition I have decided to not be nervous and just have faith!!! Note that I am trusting the guidance that 3 or 4 Warriors with Healer(s) is solid for dungeons as it isn't a group composition I ran in Vanilla, BC, nor WoTLK. If my memory is correct my favorite PVE Dungeon MB group makeup was Paladin Tank + 4 Shaman (one deep Resto with Earth Shield) from BC on-wards and I mainly did ranged casting groups so melee-cleave will be new for me...

Note that if pre-cast buffs do indeed carry over into BGs I had planned on doing a 2nd mixed class team to be able to summon our mains to the BG vendors/queue locations and to buff them before going into the BGs. I don't really want to run a mixed team for dungeon grinding (I like my 3 DPS to be similar to reduce complexity) and just look at my mixed team as a way to portal/summon/buff/feed/water/stonex2 our main Paladins and Warrior(s) for max BG performance. Any extra money-making professions on them are just gravy as our main focus is optimal BG performance on/for our mains...