Quote Originally Posted by Mannyman
Which group do you prefer Caldyn, the pally or warrior group?

Swap the warrior for a pally, and that's pretty much my group
Depends on the instance, with pally I can do Non Heroic BM, with warrior I can't since I have to focus one toon on dpsing the adds that fly by, with Paladin I can consecrate and hold aggro, full dps on the elite then follow and aoe all the adds when the elite is near dead. Warrior can't do that.

Shattered Halls is easy with Paladin aoe tanking vs warrior trying to hold 3 elites 2 sheeps, overall more difficult in that instance.

Mtin'g main heroic bosses and adds are easier with the warrior, I take less risk of dying/wiping, there's more hp and mitigation from warrior than paladin. Single boss aggro management is > than Paladin. In Karazhan / Prince, I eventually and obviously start losing aggro over the duration of the fight vs the warrior, and wind up taking more crushing blows vs warrior.

HP right now is 14k warrior vs 10.5k paladin hp. Warrior gear up to 490 defense can be swapped with mitigation type gear, block/dodge/parry gear. The Paladin due to aggro management needs to have spell damage in as much as possible if you plan to hold aggro longer + hp, so you have to balance out x amount of total spell damage vs x amount of mitigation.

Overall though, Paladin is better 5 man instance then warrior at the moment.