Classic thought on follow/pvp realm

[nodoze]

Personally, I always prefer double healer. 3 Warriors is plenty of DPS and having that extra HPS really smooths things out. Especially since I play alliance and paladins only have single target heals.

Instead of 2 Paladin's healing did you ever try converting one Paladin to Tank and dish out DPS and then have one of the Paladin's keep Seal of Light up on the enemy?

If your Warriors were running dual Crusader Enchants on something like FlurryAxe+ThrashBlade with HandOfJustice (or IronFoe instead of FlurryAxe) I would think they should be getting lots of little Healing from both Crusader Enchants and the Seal of Light's Judgement.

Hopefully that kind of setup would help smooth things out well for one healer to generally manage and the DPSing Tank Paladin can still be a periodic off Healer to supplement the healing of any spikes. If that ends up being too mana intensive you could try to weave in Judging Seal of Wisdom so hits on the target help refill both health and mana for the Paladin(s).

[Apatheist]

Instead of 2 Paladin's healing did you ever try converting one Paladin to Tank and dish out DPS and then have one of the Paladin's keep Seal of Light up on the enemy?

I would be judging wisdom/light and meleeing with the two paladins either way. Seal/judgement of wisdom actually regen a ton of mana and since IWT works it's well worth the effort of making sure your healer is in melee range for PvE.

Protection paladins use a ton of mana even if you're being conservative. I wouldn't want to play one without a mage in the group for water. Having two holy paladins allows you to be super mana efficient with flash of light and healing separate targets when the mobs are split between your warriors.