I pretty much did that already.

The steps are a bit different but what I come to is the NVIDIA Control Panel and under display I am able to select "Set up Multiple Displays". The only option I have in the setup is, "Only use one display (single)" and no other options for other displays. I am able to swap the monitor by selecting the other monitor as the one I want to use so I know they are both being detected by the computer. Even the tool tip on the page is telling me that I can select "clone" or "Dualview" but they are not selectable.