I believe this thread has run it's course. If you're looking for a TL;DR I'd suggest this bit from Ughmahedhurtz:

Quote Originally Posted by Ughmahedhurtz View Post
I think we can probably sum up this th read for future visitors or reporters as: "If you do bot-like or gold-farmer-like things, especially semi-afk stuff where you really aren't paying much attention, expect to have a bad day eventually. If you're *really* polite and complete on your appeals, you have a good chance of getting it overturned. Still, Blizzard is not the judicial system -- don't get bent out of shape when you realize Blizzard runs an invite-only club."