Sam DeathWalker 5.4 28 Box SOLO of Galleon

[Sam DeathWalker]

I am up for any fair challenge but I don’t really see how you are able to compare a 5 boxer to a 25 boxer or even a 25 boxer to a 40 boxer. How do you compare a 5 boxer to a 10 boxer?

I’m like in the heavyweight boxing division and I claim I can beat anyone in any division, thus I am the most powerful, you are claiming to be like ‘pound for pound” the best due to superior skill at a lighter weight. Both claims can be true. Character for Character the Warlock did better than I did, yet there is no question I am more powerful overall.

For someone who boxes fewer than 25 in a 25 man raid the raid itself changes, I get no credit for the substantial skill I put in before the battle.

Just as a 5 boxer who is forced to do 1 man content will be beat by a 1 boxer because the 1 boxer didn’t have to level up 5 characters.

No reasonable person will say that the 5 boxer warlock team is more powerful than my 28 man team, if we were to meet in pvp I would slaughter him. Just like no reasonable person would say that a single character with higher ilevel then the warlocks is more powerful or better than the 5 warlocks because the one character was able to do something the 5 were not.

Wasn’t there some kind of guild vs. guild pvp? Did that get implemented? What is that training thing about is that viable?

If the 5 boxer or 10 boxer or 15 boxer has to enter a 25 man raid, with 25 then drop all the characters that he does not control so that the raid is the same I have to face then sure, I will compare against anyone that has to go against the exact same opponent or conditions that I have to.

Basically you want me to throw out 23 of my guys and run 5 of my weaker against your 5 stronger, or course you will win, just as if you have to go up against swifty one v one you will lose.

You don’t require someone like the warlocks to take off his ilevel 540 gear to compare with others in 490 ilevel gear to make it “fair”. And you don’t’ require a level 90 to delevel to level 85 before he can claim to be more powerful than the level 85.

When I was being camped by a 5 boxer 5 or so levels higher than me and he wiped me out I didn’t see anyone complain that it wasn’t “fair”, and I didn’t claim it was unfair either (it’s a pvp server) knowing that someday the tables would turn. Now that I destroy a 5 boxer suddenly I am “unreasonable” and “unfair”.

I would think the next target is Oon or the celestials, but if you can come up with something else that is fair I am up for it.

We picked a mob that all can attack (I picked Galleon but you guys came up with Nalak) and I say ok throw whatever you have against it and kill it, and of those who were able to do it the one who did it the fastest is the best, and somehow you say I am unreasonable?

Also Mirai you might want to look up some of the old posts in this forum and review the very first few posts by Lax. There were many who objected to Lax posting on this forum, yet one voice spoke up in his defense when others would not, and that one lone voice was me.

Also my support for IsBoxer is unwavering, I doubt I would be able to do what I do without Isboxer, and much credit for my great accomplishments should go to Lax and IsBoxer.

Anyway think about how to compare a 5 boxer to a 10 boxer and be fair to both, recognizing the 5 boxer will have higher ilevels but the 10 boxer has twice as many accounts. And you can’t force the 10 boxer to fight 5 man content, just like you can’t force the 5 boxer to fight 1 man content.

I am sure we all agree that some kind of ladder or competition to compare all would be fun and enjoyable.

Basically I am accepting your challenge but with the condition that I compare against others, not some unknown yardstick and they must be in a 25 man normal raid, as I will be in.