Sam DeathWalker 5.4 28 Box SOLO of Galleon

[Sam DeathWalker]

I agree that taking down Nalak with 5 is a greater accomplishment then Galleon with 28 (although I would be interested to see how he does against galleon).

I also agree that it takes more skill to do what he did.

Still I find it very hard to concede that he is more powerful overall, even though Nalak must be considered a stronger mob then Galleon, given he is a 5 boxer and I am a 28 boxer.

Sure my ilevel is like 500ish and his is 540ish but still 28 v. 5? I slaughter 5 simultaneous opponents in pvp every day, regardless of their ilevel. A group of 5 is nothing to me.

I would like him to post a world of logs of his accomplishment also for study, as I do with my accomplishments.

I am still going to claim most powerful based upon numbers but concede that he is more skillful and that his accomplishment is greater than mine.

I’ll work on beating his time on Nalak which really should not be hard for mages. It’s odd that void walkers can tank Nalak, I can’t see void walkers tanking Galleon and his adds at all. Clearly there is something easy about Nalak that escapes me which is why I would like a world of logs to study.

[Tsumi]

I agree that taking down Nalak with 5 is a greater accomplishment then Galleon with 28 (although I would be interested to see how he does against galleon).

I also agree that it takes more skill to do what he did.

Still I find it very hard to concede that he is more powerful overall, even though Nalak must be considered a stronger mob then Galleon, given he is a 5 boxer and I am a 28 boxer.

Sure my ilevel is like 500ish and his is 540ish but still 28 v. 5? I slaughter 5 simultaneous opponents in pvp every day, regardless of their ilevel. A group of 5 is nothing to me.

I would like him to post a world of logs of his accomplishment also for study, as I do with my accomplishments.

I am still going to claim most powerful based upon numbers but concede that he is more skillful and that his accomplishment is greater than mine.

I’ll work on beating his time on Nalak which really should not be hard for mages. It’s odd that void walkers can tank Nalak, I can’t see void walkers tanking Galleon and his adds at all. Clearly there is something easy about Nalak that escapes me which is why I would like a world of logs to study.

isn't Prepared running 52 characters? By your logic you can't claim, "most powerful" either if that is the case.

[zenga]

I agree that taking down Nalak with 5 is a greater accomplishment then Galleon with 28 (although I would be interested to see how he does against galleon).

And that is the whole point: it's pointless to compare accomplishments and make most/best/greatest claims based on that. Because the context is totally different every time. The boss mechanics are different, the ilvl is different, the group comp is different. Say tomorrow someone starts to box 28 affliction lock, and another one 28 ele shamans. Are you gonna split up the 'title' then into 'most powerful aoe boxer', 'most poweful dot boxer' and 'most poweful single target boxer'?

This community has always been very encouraging to post and share videos of accomplishments, from the smallest to the most impressive ones. But to my humble opinion, the 'my achievement is bigger than yours because I run more toons' ones made people post less videos (also has to do of course with just less people playing the game).

Noticing the difference between the nalak thread and this one? The nalak dude just posted a vid: 'hey guys i like to share my latest kill'. Your thread could've been easily the same, but it's full of provocations and contradictions. Really there is no point whatsoever to claim to be the best or most powerful.