Auto-activate CTM on slaves is off. CTM under interface options is also off.

I'm really sorry for not clarifying. My hunter/priest combo is Psalms and Proverbs (Psalms is the priest, Proverbs is the hunter) of Dalaran, the team name is Bible. ;P The teams that work as expected are Chevis/Sora (retpally/mage), and Hunters (hunt/hunt).

These characters are level one or level two (can't remember offhand). Hunter has Arcane Shot on Key #1, Priest has Smite on Key #1. When I target something and Push 1 on the hunter, the hunter shoots it, but the priest, instead of remaining where she is and starting to cast Smite, runs to the target and swings at it. Sometimes she'll stop and cast Smite after whacking the target with her mace, but other times she'll run around it in circles. Key mapping is on, Broadcasting is off. The run-around-in-a-circle thing would be nice if she were a rogue or a melee class, but she's not. I want her to stand back with the hunter and cast Smite instead.

Just noticed that this ONLY happens with 1. With 2, 3, 4, et cetera, the priest stands back and casts. This might actually be an easy fix! Yay. I'm not sure how to fix it, though-- or if fixing it on these characters will screw it up on the ret paladin/mage. For now I can just move the buttons to 2-etc, I guess. Thanks for the help guys, sorry about my amazing noobishness.