I did LFR a few times with Fishbeak today and we had an idea. With the size of our guild on KJ Alliance, we could easily fill the 16 DPS slots on a raid.

We would just bring a clothie, boomkin, shammy/hunter, and plate DPS that hadn't done LFR before and cover all the other DPS spots with toons who had already run it and couldn't roll. That way when DPS drops occur, there would be no competition. Heck, boxing 8 DPS is the exact same level of effort as "boxing" one for me and we'd guarantee guildies would get DPS drops if we ran this way. Same for tank/heal loot of course, but that might require more effort.

Another nice thing is that doing it that way would be a great benefit for all the other random healers and tanks that ran with us since there would be so few people rolling on tier pieces. Our DPS seem to be in the middle of the pack on the runs I've been on anyway, so it isn't like we'd be hurting the raid with low deeps. Seems like a win for everyone involved.