So I opened a ticket and finally got a response:
Number 2 is a little annoying, since I don't have any good way of knowing the expiration date of cards that have been replaced now. Though it is interesting that using a credit card makes the process worse with two extra questions to answer.Before we can give you information on the accounts we need to establish that you are the original owner. Therefore we ask you to please provide the information listed below. Note that it is vital that the information provided is as accurate and detailed as possible.
1. The full name used when the accounts were created (your name).
2. The last 6 digits and the expiration date of the credit card used to pay for the subscriptions (if a credit card was used).
3. The billing address for the credit card used to pay for the subscriptions (if a credit card was used).
4. The date of birth registered at account creation.
Thank you for your patience and cooperation.
Best regards,
GM Spotted
EVE Online Customer Support Team
Luckily for me I found an old EveMon config file that has all my accounts and at least one character name. Even with this info, getting past the security check is a pain. Entering the correct information still refuses your login, claiming you entered it incorrectly... for the first couple attempts. Then it lets you in with exact same info. Gotta love QA on those rarely used features.
TL;DR; - I lucked out and got around this.
This space for rent.
Connect With Us