Talking to Bornakk about Raid Rewards in Cata

[jinkobi]

I like the rewards but hate Blizzard's philosphy as to why they're doing it. People will be forced to stay in guilds they dislike because they're invested.

Blizz said they want to penalize for changing guild. Why?? What's the damned point. Just seems like some half-baked idea that a developer with a wild hair up his ass came up with. Creating a problem where no problem even existed.

Guilds come and go all the time just keep up with you server forums. Where there's people there will be drama. What if the guild leader just turns into a total douche...

It's taking away our freedom to choose without suffering a penalty.

[Iceorbz]

You guys are full of tinfoil hats and the sky is falling. I really doubt its going to be so hard to get these perks back when you switch guilds. I'm not in a guild on beta or I would give you more info; but really, nothing is ever that hard. Your qqing for really nothing.

As far as joining a "bigger guild" , if your boxing you are probably pugging with friends. What is so wrong with joining their guild, if its just your toons anyways. If they all qq and cry, turn off guild chat, unless you talk to yourself -- it will be like being in your own guild.

[OzPhoenix]

You guys are full of tinfoil hats and the sky is falling. I really doubt its going to be so hard to get these perks back when you switch guilds. I'm not in a guild on beta or I would give you more info; but really, nothing is ever that hard. Your qqing for really nothing.

As far as joining a "bigger guild" , if your boxing you are probably pugging with friends. What is so wrong with joining their guild, if its just your toons anyways. If they all qq and cry, turn off guild chat, unless you talk to yourself -- it will be like being in your own guild.

Actually Iceorbz, I don't see anyone here whipping out the tinfoil hats or claiming that the sky is falling and I'm disappointed that you would say that - it's the sort of hyperbolic argument that I'd hope we could keep out of these forums (especially as since the Blizzard forums have become almost useless due to the community there).

For myself, and I pretend to speak for no-one other than myself, I am merely disappointed at Blizzards anti-small guild attitude - and merely stating opposition is not QQ.

Finally, you still haven't stated (and nor has Blizzard I'll give you that) what's actually wrong with allowing small guilds a full scope of participation in these guild leveling benefits.