I was stuck under 1800 for what seemed an eternity until I changed my spell pen from 50 to 123. After reviewing the combat logs for some matches, it was clear that enough of my spell damage was being resisted to make or break a match. In addition, I went with all the ascendency gear for the +hit, so now i'm sitting at 150 hit (before precision), 123 spell pen, ~3450 SP with ToW glyphed, and just over 24k HP (tauren racial).

We were on the cusp of 1900 (1895) and xferred, and seem to be in the same boat. We can get crazy close to 1900, but just can't seem to break over it. I blame part of it for being this late in the season, but the reality is that most high level teams that have faced us, know what works against us, so it's very hard to move up now. In order for us to win, we have to play close to perfect.