Farming Shadow's Edge

[remanz]

The thing is what can how effective can a godly 2h be in a 5 man melee group. You spend a lot of effort getting one where you still need 4 others. People on my server are trading 5 Primordial Saronite for 1 battered hilt. This badass axe takes 25 Primordial Saronite. That's 5 251 2h that you can get for your team.

But if you are talking about using your team to feed just 1 character for raiding. Then ya, totally doable. For me, 5 x 251 2h sword vs 1 x Shadow's Edge + a possibility of getting legendary later. I will take 5 x 251 2h for my team.

Also, armor penetration is not a good stat for dk + paladin. Only 35% of paladin and dk's damage are helped by ARP.

this thing is much more attractive (would be insane in pvp) and far more easily obtainable.

[item=50415]Bryntroll, the Bone Arbiter[/item]