How many procs you do you get off your healing egg trinket? I only ever got procs upon dropping totems with the BRD version.

The damage meter is a bad way of looking at the damage since you have very lengthy dps to zero mana time and a very choppy dps cycle. I would back up a step, and look at the size of the normal / crits for your lightning bolts and lava blast rather than the damage meter. As well as the crit rate.

If your at 12k bursts and so forth, I would suspect your clicking the dps button at a goofy rate, Niley has some thoughts on over button mashing.