I voted for the G13.

I was a die hard N52 user for a good couple of years but recently bought the G13.
I struggled to use it at first - I found the thumb joystick awkward after the N52's D-Pad.

However I've been using it for solo play for a little while now - and I love it.
More than enough keys. It's comfortable, I've grown used to the thumb joystick too.

I did have issues with the binding software. Seemed a bit temperamental on whether it loaded or not or saved changes. In the end made use of the export facility whenever i changed it and not had a problem since.

I'm not using all of the keys - don't hold my hand on it's home keys, but absolutely love it.


I should say I also have a g19 keyboard on my machine upstairs - and don't bother with it.
The G13 is more natural, and allows me to swap over from mouse movement to joystick movement instantly (for example when I want to position a shadowfury).

BIg thumbs up from me - and apologies for the huge wall of text.