Are you running Recount? Just curious what the numbers show.

I'm leveling my B-Team right now, and one of them is a 61 Ret Pallie. I just wrote a /click macro for him last night. He's in almost all greens and has a crappy weapon, but is still pulling about 450 DPS. So if you're not at least getting that, you definitely want to re-write your macros.

I'm at work right now or i'd post them for you.