FOUND IT!
although the ";" at the end of each line did help...
the ultimate fix was keybinds...

The problem:
Only some of the slaves were responding to the follow macro.

The hint:
It worked perfectly on a trial account with no keybinds setup except for the follow macro.

The Fix:
My follow macro was bound to "w" on all toons.
I had my 7th "secondary action button" bound to SHIFT+W !!!!
Unbound the 7th "secondary action button" and watched my 10hours worth of effort on a follow macro work seamlessly on all toons.

Why this makes sense:
since my "hidden" keybinds were set to CTRL+SHIFT+W or ALT+SHIFT+W and variations of it, someone was getting confused along the way (whether that be keyclone or wow), and trying to press two buttons at once.
Which leads me to believe its impossible to press two buttons at once, which makes complete sense.

This problem/solution needs to be stickied, I dont want anyone to go thru what I had to, or they will be very upset with the entire dual boxing experience. And/or Keyclone.

My message for Keyclone: If this was made simpler, I would definitely pay to get another license! And the program would easily be worth 20+

Thanks all for the help!


The final configuration:
(no keymaps have been changed since thread opened)

The Macro:
/target [mod:ctrl,mod:shift,nomod:alt,target=zauberzuerst];[mod:ctrl,mod:alt,nomod:shift,target=zaubermorgue];[mod:alt,mod:shift,nomod:ctrl,target=zaubereiz];[mod:ctrl,mod:alt,mod:shift,target=zaubernebel];
/follow
/say %t

REMEMBER the following literal example: <constitutes a key>
"/target<space>[all modifiers on one line]<;>
/(spell or etc that you want to perform)

(the /say %t was for testing purposes)


Thats all I got.