Quote Originally Posted by Multibocks View Post
I tried regular of ToC on my paladin group. Was loltastic. Stupid ROGUE, I HATE YOU. Why is it that groups are never really punished for bringing lots of ranged dps, yet there are LOTS of encounters I can think of that punish you for bringing melee dps. WTF blizzard.
You're not being actively punished, it's just not very evenly designed. Whirlwinds and other point-blank AOE are easy tricks when it comes to boss fights, and the developers are leaning on them more heavily than they should. They don't have anything against melee groups, but IMO they need to schedule the time to come up with some more boss attacks that don't follow the anti-melee template.