Quote Originally Posted by Fursphere
Fights are also situational, warrior/druid/paladin have advantages one way, vs another way. Paladins aoe tank the best, but against same boss, will take more damage vs a warrior/druid, etc... (this is also a discussion onto itself.)
Disagree. Since you want to talk about specifics, if you take a Paladin and a Warrior with approx. equal gear and similar specs (prot - prot), the Paladin will do better on the last boss of Ramparts.

Why? Fire Aura and a ranged taunt. Warriors won't get any way of pulling a mob back from range until 70 (Intervene, which isn't exactly a taunt either).
AOE side paladin was an example. Again, just so that you understand. (this is also a discussion onto itself.) I even bolded to to make it easier on your eyes.

I can do Heroic Ramparts fine with my Warrior, Druid or Paladin tanking. I don't need to rely on Fire Resist gear or Aura, nor do I need to pull out theories vs actually doing it.