My pally :http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...reaver&n=Phean

My Dk: http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...aver&n=Lowpass


I love my paladin, the rotation is easier and mobs stick to you right away, also having aoe down all the time helps, other than dks spell damage debuff, there is nothing that dk can do better than paladin come 3.2. If paladins go unchanged into that patch they will be best tanks all around. On the ptr my dk can barely break 30k hp too, they might end up being lowest hp tanks after all.

Paladin:
-blessings
-aoe down all the time
-"raid save" if you spec into it
-lay on hands
-very good threat generation
-can heal or dps also
-crusader aura(great for dailies, shaves 8 minutes of my full run)
-easier to gear for, no need to worry about being hit capped or exp capped as much as on dk
-Auto save come 3.2

DK
-Spell damage debuff
-better saves than paladin(until 3.2)
-can dps also
-AoE has 5s cd in between, but can be used anywhere within certain range not just under the tank.
-Best tanks until 3.2