Are you running as a main or an alt? That's the real question. My guild runs EPGP, mains get first dibs, then alts or offspecs roll off for the leftovers. If you regularly bring your clones, then it's in the guild's best interest to gear them up, but I wouldn't roll over a main. Each of your alts should get a roll imo if no main wants it, offspec and alt gear - it's not forcing progression so who cares. But you should divy out gear so your #2 is better geared than #3 and #4 and so on. That way, if only 2 are needed, you bring your best team possible. No sense spreading out good gear all over if you're not always going to need all 5.