As many here, I am 5x boxing. Since there are 11 primary tradeskills, at least one have to be missing from my group.

I hate not being able to pick everything I run across, so I'd like to have all the gathering professions.
But I also hate missing on BOP recipes (I know that, at the moment, some professions don't have BOP recipes in northrend.but that would change so..) so I'd like to have all the crafting tradeskills.

At the moment I am torn between ditching out Herbalism or Jewelcrafting.

Jewelcrafting because the pg I play solo is a Jewelcrafter/miner.
Herbalism because it just gives that crappy self hot, and I don't have it on my main (mining/eng) so it's not that great.


I don't think I will actively farm herbs, once I max the profession I'll just pick up whatever I stumble upon.
Jewelcrafting has some nice BOP gems, the BOP recipes (not that great, however) and the ability to craft gems without switching to my solo char, but I would lose the herbs.

What do you think guys?