[quote='Benjamen',index.php?page=Thread&postID=1836 48#post183648]as numerous "magic" crits from the other guy which is expected.[/quote]

This could have changed but I'm pretty sure that mobs can't get magic based crits on you. I'll probably do that same fight tonight so I'll check it out; maybe it's a problem with recount.

Again, his avoidance is pretty low, particular his dodge so he's getting a lot of non-blocked hits (normal hits). Tanks get some pretty decent mitgation with block value so pushing those avoidance + block % numbers up really really helps.

I just got started in heroics too; UK is the ONLY heroic I have cleared (twice now). I don't have any gear from heroics, everything is quested, crafted or rep rewards and my dodge is at 20%, twice as much as his. So, have your friend really work on his gear. While I'm still working on my gear too, you can use it as a reference as just about everything I have is attainable before heroic ([url='http://www.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Kilrogg&n=Talamarr']Talamarr[/url]

I have a feeling that gear is the issue here.