All heroics cleared 5 boxing

[Alemi]

But not impossible.

Depends. Some encounters *cough* Oculus*cough* really punish some set ups *hackcough*melee*hack*.

Not that any encounter is necesarily impossible, but 4 shamans and a tank doesn't cover every possible boxing configuration.

Number 1 - as was said by other posters, I made no supposition that EVERY combination of classes could box heroics. Never. That's something you inferred. What I said was that they are boxable. I used to run 5 shaman, there's no way I'd have this success with that setup. I thought this would be obvious.

Number 2 - If you're boxing melee that's your own call, but it can be more difficult (on most encounters - before someone takes that out of context) than boxing tank/3 ranged dps/1 healer. However, there are equally as many encounters that are extremely ranged UNfriendly, or more difficult.