i was thinking about my last post and i think i should at least tell you what you should do in a fight, especially since you RAF'ed the pally. i guess you dont have a clue what skills to use and all that as well as not knowing the stats and talents. so... here's what i did... AT 60-ish.

equip quest rewards (STAM and STR stats the priority. dont worry about the plate sets with INT or MP5 or any of that other stuff aimed at holy).
shield from quest reward is fine. 1hander, any kind, sword, axe, mace.

pre-battle:
ret aura or devotion aura. either works.
have shield spike on.
blessing of sanctuary.
seal of anything. vengeance/corruption on bosses only.
always fight vs. 3+ mobs. any less and your mana regen will suck. four is optimal for solo, 5+ with healer or dps of any kind.

battle:
start battles one of two ways... leave your team in a spot. mount up. run around and gather mobs to bring back to the group. or... use avenger shield. either one works.
consecrate ground.
holy shield (reflective holy damage)
Hammer of the righteous (based on dps of your weapon convered into holy damage, hitting 3 guys)
These are your bread and butter AoE attacks.

micro manage the mobs:
pick one mob. hammer of justice it. one stunned mob = one less mob dealing damage. use it whenever its off cooldown.
pick any mob. judge light/wisdom/whatever. your choice. make sure this mob is the one you and your dps are concentrating on. once he's down in health and will die soon, you can either finish him off with Hammer of Wrath, or... switch targets and Judge another mob with higher health and let the previous mob die from consecrate/holyshield/spikes.

if a mob runs, it means he's dying. use hammer of wrath.
if you're full on mana, use avenger shield at close range. works wonderfully... IF you have enough mana to spare.
if you need to use your taunt on a mob.... here's a great macro:
/cast [help] [target=targettarget, help] Righteous Defense
either target the slave that's being attacked, or better yet, target the mob that's attacking said slave.

if you're running low on mana, there's two things you need to check. one, you dont have enough mobs. two, make sure your blessing of sanc is on. in fact, go to the reagent vendor and buy 100 symbol of kings so you can cast Greater Blessing of Sanc/might/wisdom.

ok... try that out. and tweak your attack sequence to your liking. this will last you alll the way til you get shield of rightesouness. then you'll just need to add that into the mix. but thats way later on.