Yep, I came to the same conclusion on my 1+4 team. I kept one hunter in Marks for TSA and the extra toy or two. I think the 10%x3 AP barely edges out the pure BM spec for raw dps. Surv is way too fidgety for boxing, IMO.

I kinda like the idea of running a true tank alongside the hunters, though. Hmm. Maybe a DK with a Pally healer? What led you to pick the WAR instead? Raw challenge?