I followed your Spread out macro exactly and I got it to work for Toon 1 and Toon 2.

However when I try it on Toon 3 and Toon 4 it seems that Toon both Toon 1 and Toon 3 go the exact same way both times. Even though in my keymaps they are mapped to different directions. I totally don't get it.

I even redid the keymap again just in case I did something wrong, but I don't get why I am having this problem cause I really don't see it in the keymaps.