Repalacing that pally tank with a DK in WOLK?

[Aethon]

If might work, as DK's have a lot of AoE abilities.

But so do warriors. So far its hard to tell which class is the best aoe tank in wotlk.

Hmm are you playing the same warrior class i am ?

Seriously warriors are the worst AoE style tanking class. TC only hits 4 targets, demo shout is well meagre threat at best.

Cleave is a terrible way to dump rage, and whirlwind well if your tanking in zerker stance you should reroll.

They are now getting this cone type attack which in theory looks nice. But with the cooldown on it as it currently and stunning mobs i dont see it to viable.

Stunning is bad for your rage generation. And besides that playing warrior is much more keybinding intensive then lets say play a paladin.

just fyi i got a 70 prot warrior, and a 70 prot pala. I use the warrior for single boxing since its more fun to tank with, however the pala is much easier to tank with when boxing.

I agree with one exception: If you can tank in zerker stance, you f'ing rock and are way better at healing your tank then I ever was.