For me, I like the newer model, as it takes up less space on my pullout, without having to move it constantly. I'm not really sure why I got it besides that it's a Logitech and I own alot of their products. I never bother with the macro keys, so having less never bother me. I still think the lcd screen is more gimmick then anything, as I hardly have time to look at it while gaming. I got it on sale for $79 and also the new G9[same price] so I'm not complaining.