Lorune, Moredots and Puppychow all have accurate reviews.

Lorune's post immediately comes off as negative, but highlights lacking areas as being PvE elements. I gather that Lorune plays MMOs for the PvE/co-op, exploration, seeing all content side of things. His opinion is duely noted.

Moredots and Puppychow, after only experiencing Beta, have positive comments about PvP.

I was sold a long time ago on the whole RvR concept. I never did play DAoC, but if WAR seems similar to WoW, but is more PvP focused, where my PvP affects the outcome of the greater cause and there isn't just end-game PvP to look forward to, the idea sounds fantastic.

Now, I just leave it up to the developers to take their wonderful concept and make it work and be fun. Balance, realizing it'll never be perfect, will play a major role.