New 3box - Pally or DK

[Mootallica]

I'm starting a threebox team with two priests and a tank. Would I be better off with a DK tank or a Pally tank for this trio?

[Boylston]

Either is fine, really. You don't provide enough information for us to give you a solid recommendation.

Your new team, are you going to PvP with it? What are your goals in PvE/PvP? How are you intending to level them up?

You're not going to get a useful recommendation without providing more information.

[Mootallica]

Thanks for the reply, I suppose you're right.

This will be a pve dungeon team only. One dungeon at a time as they progress. I'm hoping to take advantage of the instant casts the priests have without needing to face the target at all times. Vamp embrace stacks, renew stacks, and I'm hoping this will be enough healing on trash mobs to make the group sustainable.
I know right off the bat the Pally has a talent to increase the healing done, however the DK has a lot of passive heals as well. I'm not sure what direction to go in regards to both classes and the payability while multiboxing.

Thanks for any feedback you may have to offer =)

[Boylston]

http://www.dual-boxing.com/showthread.php?t=27946

http://www.dual-boxing.com/showthread.php?t=29000

http://www.dual-boxing.com/showthread.php?t=30205

Learn to use the advanced search.


So, as to your question, I think Pally is probably a better choice for PvE. For one thing, they can provide a nice set of buffs for the Priests. Also, you can start off with the Pally at L1 and use him for instances from 1-58. A DK is going to force you to wait a little while longer before you add a true tank to the team.